
SOURCE: Kansas City Business Journal
AUTHOR: Charlie Anderson, Staff Writer
Originally published in the June 24, 2005 print edition of the Kansas City Business Journal.
Exchange will take on Wall Street
Electronic network will compete with NYSE, Nasdaq plans
The founder of Tradebot Systems Inc. is launching an electronic stock exchange in a bid to inject competition into the rapidly consolidating industry.
BATS Trading Inc.
BATS is an acronym for "better alternative trading system" -- is in the development stage, but Tradebot CEO Dave Cummings said he wants to launch the electronic communications network early next year "There's room in the marketplace," he said.
Tradebot is one of Kansas City's most cutting-edge technology companies. Based in North Kansas City, it trades about 50 million to 100 million shares of stock a day, including a sizable daily volume of stocks such as Microsoft Corp., Yahoo! Inc. and Google Inc.
That makes Tradebot one of the largest customers of the big electronic communications networks, such as Archipelago Holdings LLC.
ECNs are electronic exchanges that match stock traders through fast Internet connections.
On April 20, Archipelago announced plans to merge with the New York Stock Exchange. Shortly thereafter, Nasdaq announced merger plans with another large ECN, Instinet Group Inc.
Cummings said he sees the news as an attempt by the exchanges to be the only game in town for traders.
"I believe market share should be earned, not bought," Cummings said in a statement on the BATS Trading Web site.
Joe Ratterman, the former chief information officer of Lenexa-based LabOne Inc. who joined Tradebot last year, will be COO of BATS Trading.
"One of our primary motives is to keep competition alive," Ratterman said.
News of Cummings' plans have created buzz on Wall Street, said Adam Sussman, a senior consultant at The Tabb Group in New York. The Tabb Group provides research and consulting services to the financial industry.
Sussman said BATS Trading is the first plan for a new ECN to come out in the wake of the mega-mergers announced by the NYSE and Nasdaq.
Ratterman said a handful of electronic trading firms like Tradebot plan to build ECNs.
Tradebot makes profits in the fractions of a penny on each trade using a software-driven trading mechanism.
BATS Trading will license Tradebot's software to create the trading platform.
Sussman said BATS Trading can be successful if it undercuts the pricing of the larger ECNs.
"You disrupt the profitability of the larger ECNs and force someone to buy you to take you out," he said. "If I were starting an ECN, that's what I'd do."
One of the biggest challenges facing ECNs is getting enough traders in the system to make it worthwhile for large-scale trading of stock, said Laura Tuttle, an assistant professor at the University of Kansas School of Business. A former Nasdaq employee, Tuttle's research has included ECNs and Tradebot's technology.
Tuttle said Cummings has an advantage because he can pump Tradebot's huge volume into the system.
"I can't imagine that there's anyone out there more qualified to launch a trading platform than Dave," she said.
Cummings said he will finance the venture personally for at least the first six months of development. After that, he said, he will look for outside investors, hire a management team and open an operations center in the New York-New Jersey area.
"I really like building a company, taking it from zero to 30 people," Cummings said.
Ratterman and Cummings said they can build an ECN for less money than Archipelago did
Archipelago piled up losses of $39 million, $38 million and $35 million in 2000, 2001 and 2002, respectively.
Cummings said times have changed.
"That was a dot-com era," he said. "We think we can do it for a few million dollars."